Suffolk Humanists

For a good life, without religion

Julian Baggini asks if living without religion means living without hope

Posted by Margaret on Tuesday, Jul 3, 2012

Julian BagginiIn the latest New Humanist magazine, philosopher Julian Baggini says that one of religion’s attractions to the religious is that it offers hope, and asks if living without religion means living without it.

Most atheists accept that Hope is essential to life, as AC Grayling put it to me, a beautiful, central thing in all our lives. Philosopher Nigel Warburton, recalling the inscription Abandon all hope, ye who enter here at the entrance of Dantes Hell, told me, Hell is not having hope. But both reject the claim that hope requires religion. Its not that atheists dont have hopes, says Warburton, they just have different hopes. Among these Grayling lists hopes for the improvement of mankind, for greater justice in society, for more people to love more other people.

Maybe one of the problems with religion is that it offers hope based on totally unrealistic expectations?

Posts by year

Suffolk Humanists © 2022